Multiple black hole systems in active galaxies
H. Pietilä has concluded a study of the evolution of binary
black hole systems in the nuclei of galaxies. The problem of the
timescale of the evolution of a binary black hole in the center
of the galaxy is not simple. The most troublesome
points are the wide and skewed distributions of the changes of
energy and especially angular momentum in a single encounter of
a star and the binary. A definite solution requires a more
detailed model of the galaxy core and its evolution.
The work suggests that the interactions of the binary with the
stars in the nucleus do not make the binary coalesce, i.e. the
binaries can survive over the Hubble time in the nucleus of an
isolated galaxy. P. Heinämäki has studied what happens to the
binary system when the galaxy is not isolated but merges with
other major galaxies. Then three or four black hole systems may
form in the centre of the merger. Evolutionary scenarios have
been constructed using the cosmological halo merger models of
Lacey & Cole. It was found that the frequency of two sided
black hole ejections is rather close to the observed frequency
of double radio sources, and that the symmetry properties of
the ejected pairs can be made to match the symmetry properties
of double radio sources if reasonable observational selection
biases are assumed.
M.Valtonen, P.Heinämäki, H. Lehto, and A.Chernin studied the
basic physical characteristics of chaos in three-body dynamics,
in connection with the concept (put forward earlier by Valtonen
and coworkers) of multiple supermassive black holes as the most
convincing source of energy in quasars and active galactic
nuclei. With the use of long time series generated by the model
of three black holes confined in the potential well of a
galaxy, the phenomenon of intermittence was found in three-body
chaos. The shape of the series proved to be similar to one of
type-III intermittence known in hydrodynamical flows with
transition to turbulence. It was argued that the physical
parameters of three-black-hole chaos could be revealed in the
gravitational radiation of quasars and AGNs. The space projects
of giant low-frequency gravitational antennas planned for the
next century (LISA and others) could make possible the
detection of gravitational radiation "light curves" from these
objects which might be expected to have the same shape as the
long time series (above a threshold level of the antenna
sensitivity) studied in the models.
The violently variable quasar OJ287 has kept several staff
members busy during the period. The expected fade in February 1998
was observed in optical by H. Pietilä et al. but not in radio.
The significance of this observation has been studied from the
point of view of the binary black hole model (which made the
prediction) and by using the Marscher & Gear jet model. The
conclusions of this work by M. Valtonen, H. Lehto and H.
Pietilä is that the optical and radio emitting regions in the
jet are closer than 0.1 pc from the central black hole. The
radio emitting region seems to be directly connected with the
accretion disk at about 12 Schwarzschild radii from the centre,
i.e. the jet is probably magnetically collimated by a magnetic
field which is connected to this region of the disk. The
viewing angle relative to the jet line appears to be very
small, smaller than the jet opening angle. H. Pietilä has
calculated a new solution for the binary black hole model using
the fade data. It specifies the parameters of the model very
accurately, and also makes predictions of the future and past
(both known and unknown) outburst events with the accuracy of a
few days.
Radio variability of active galactic nuclei
The largest and longest-running astronomical research project
in Finland, total flux density monitoring of active galaxies,
has been going on since 1980. Using the Metsähovi 13.7 m radio
telescope (Kirkkonummi, Finland) and the 15-m SEST telescope
(LaSilla, Chile), over 40 000 individual millimeter flux
measurements of over 100 active galaxies have been obtained
since the beginning of the joint program between the Tuorla
Observatory and the Metsähovi Radio Observatory (HUT). The only
comparable effort is the University of Michigan monitoring
program, which, however, monitors only the cm-flux variations
and therefore cannot penetrate as deep into the radio core
regions.
The program is led jointly by E. Valtaoja and S. Urpo (HUT),
with M. Tornikoski (HUT) responsible for the SEST observing
programs. Over twenty senior and junior researchers and
students from Tuorla, HUT and Helsinki University have
participated in the observations and related investigations.
This unique database is also extensively used in international
collaborative projects. Over 70 refereed publications, fifteen
of them in 1997-1998, and five doctoral theses attest to the
vigor of this venerable research program.
E. Valtaoja and M. Lainela, together with A. Lähteenmäki and
H.Teräsranta from HUT, have developed a new technique for
modelling the total flux density variations in AGN. They have
found that the radio variations can be well modelled by a
superposition of a small number of exponential flares plus a
constant contribution from the underlying unperturbed jet. To a
good approximation, each synchrotron flare produced by a new
shock can be modelled with just two parameters: the variability
timescale and the peak flux. Considering the wide variety of
AGN luminosities, the diversity of observed VLBI structures and
relativistic jet speeds, this is a rather surprising result,
and its physical reasons are as yet unknown.
The flux decomposition technique opens up a wealth of
possibilities. Valtaoja, Lähteenmäki and K. Wiik have estimated
the Doppler boosting factors for a number of radio sources
using their variability brightness temperatures obtained from
the exponential flare fits. Comparing these with traditional
(sychrotron-self-Compton) boosting factors obtained using VLBI
and X-ray data, they have found that the highest intrinsic
brightness temperatures in synchrotron sources seem to reach
only the equipartition value of approx. 5 × 1010 K
instead the usually
assumed Compton catastrophe limit of approx. 1012 K.This changes
significantly all the previous estimates of relativistic
effects, jet flow speeds, viewing angles, etc., in compact
radio sources. Investigations of the improved Doppler boosting
factors and their impact on, e.g., AGN unification-scenarios,
are in progress.
Very long baseline interferometry
The Finnish VLBI program is a spin-off of the AGN monitoring
program. High resolution interferometry is a natural companion
to high frequency flux density observations, since both probe
the parsec-scale structure around the supermassive black holes.
Turku University has contributed over 1.5 million FIM towards
the instrumentation required for VLBI observations with the
Metsähovi telescope, and both Institutes continue to
participate jointly in the Russian-led RADIOASTRON and the
Japanese HALCA (formerly VSOP) space VLBI programs. The
difficult financial situation in Russia has forced the
postponement of the RADIOASTRON launch. HALCA, however, was
launched successfully in February 1997 and continues to produce
high-resolution images of radio sources. Several HALCA
observing programs have co-investigators from Tuorla and
Metsähovi.
E. Valtaoja and K. Wiik (HUT) have continued the analysis of
the first Finnish ground based VLBI observations, a three-epoch
survey of 15 AGN. As part of a Target-of-opportunity program,
Wiik and Valtaoja also observed the source AO 0235+164 with the
global CMVA (Coordinated Millimeter VLBI Array) network during
a strong flare in 1998. Another mm-VLBI target was the quasar
CTA 102 (in collaboration with F. Rantakyr", SEST). The
millimeter VLBI-observations can provide angular resolutions
exceeding even space VLBI, but the low sensitivity necessitates
that the observations are done when the sources are flaring -
another justification for the monitoring program.
Plans for the next generation space VLBI mission, ARISE, were
finalized in 1998 and presented to NASA towards the end of the
year. If the mission is approved, the orbiting radio telescope
with a 25-m inflatable mirror will start observing around 2008.
E. Valtaoja is one of the international members of the ARISE
Science Advisory Group, which drafted the proposal to NASA.
Gamma rays and other high-frequency radiation from AGN
E. Valtaoja, M. Lainela and A. Lähteenmäki (HUT) have continued
to investigate the connections between high radio frequency
variability and gamma ray flares detected by the EGRET
instrument abroad the COMPTON gamma ray satellite. An analysis
of common sources in the full Metsähovi and EGRET databases,
using the flux decomposition technique, indicates that there is
a close connection between the radio and the gamma ray states,
with significant amounts of gamma rays detected mainly when the
AGN in question is in the initial stages of a strong millimeter
flare.The most straightforward explanation is that the gamma
rays are first order SSC (synchrotron self-Compton) radiation
from shocks forming in the relativistic jets.
The participation in the large international EGRET blazar
collaboration has continued to provide complementary radio data
for the program sources and targets of opportunity. In general,
these multifrequency studies have strengthened the case for SSC
origin of gamma rays. Our monitoring has also enabled the
identification of several previously unknown gamma ray sources.
Together with graduate students M. Hanski and P. Koivisto,
E.Valtaoja is applying the flux decomposition technique to
comparisons between radio and optical variations from various
monitoring programs, and to comparisons between radio and X-ray
data from the ROSAT satellite. Both the optical and the X-ray
data are in general too sparse for the usual correlation
analysis techniques, but each individual data point can be
compared with the contemporary radio flare parameters obtained
from the radio flux decompositions.
Optical AGN studies
E. Valtaoja and A. Lähteenmäki have continued their studies of
optical hotspots in the radio lobes of active galaxies. Their
earlier NOT observations revealed the first known optical
double hotspot, in the quasar 3C 351. The single radio and
optical hot spots are presumed to be the working surfaces of
jets boring through the intergalactic medium, but the formation
mechanism of double hot spots is still disputed. Optical
synchrotron radiation must be generated by highly relativistic
electrons accelerated in situ, and the double hot spot quasar
3C 351 thus offers a laboratory for studying the interactions
between the jet and the ambient medium. New, very deep
polarized images of the 3C 351 hot spots were obtained with NOT
in June, 1997, and their analysis is ongoing.
K. Nilsson, M. Valtonen, H. Lehto together with L.R. Jones
(Southampton) and W.C. Saslaw (Virginia and Cambridge) have
studied the optical counterparts of hot spots in Cygnus A. They
interpret the results in terms of a double-twin-jet model where
there are two terminal surfaces of jets in each radio lobe. M.
Valtonen has studied the model further and has shown that the
properties of large scale jets, including the depolarization
correlations, can be very nicely explained.
Valtaoja, Flynn and X. Wan have analyzed the NOT gravitational
lens polarization monitoring data. With the good resolution
provided by NOT, the optical polarizations of individual lensed
components can be measured, and gravitational lenses can in
principle be used as 'polarization magnifiers' for studying the
magnetic fields of AGN.
Valtaoja and M. Tornikoski (HUT), together with collaborators
from the U.K., have obtained NOT images of a complete sample of
Compact Steep Spectrum (CSS) sources previously mapped with the
MERLIN radio array. The CSS sources with small radio sizes may
be either young progenitors of larger radio sources, or
alternatively sources permanently confined to subgalactic
dimensions by high gas pressures in the parent galaxies.
Analysis of the complete optical sample should differentiate
between the 'young' and the 'frustrated' source models.
Multifrequency variability campaigns
L.O. Takalo, A. Sillanpää, K. Nilsson together with the
students at the observatory have taken part in a large number
of multifrequency monitoring campaigns of blazars. Most of
these campaigns have involved simultaneous observations by RXTE
(Akn120, OJ 287), BeppoSax (Mkn 501) and EGRET (3C 279)
satellites. They have used the one meter telescope at Tuorla
and also the NOT on La Palma for the optical monitoring of
selected blazars monitored also by the satellites. Several
blazars (e.g ON 231,Mkn 421, 3C279 and BL Lac) have been
observed in outburst during the last two years. On the other
hand, both of the OJ-94 project objects,OJ 287 and 3C66A, have
declined in brightness since their long outbursts. The OJ-94
project meetings were held at Perugia (1997) and Turku (1998).
The monitoring campaigns have enhanced the collaboration with
other blazar monitoring groups. Results from some of these
monitoring campaigns have been published in a series of
articles, mostly in A&A. At the Perugia meeting it was also
decided to start a new electronic journal called Blazar Data
for publishing observational results on blazars.
Host galaxies
In collaboration with R. Falomo (Padova) and R. Scarpa (STSCI),
J. Kotilainen undertook a near-infrared imaging survey of a
complete sample of flat spectrum radio quasars (FSRQ) at
0.5 < z < 1.0. The host galaxy was clearly detected for six FSRQs,
marginally for six FSRQs, and remained unresolved for eight
FSRQs. The galaxies hosting FSRQs are very luminous,
much brighter than the typical galaxy luminosity L*, and at
least as bright as the brightest cluster galaxies. The
luminosities of the FSRQ hosts are intermediate between the
hosts of low redshift radio-loud quasars and BL Lac objects,
and the hosts of high redshift radio-loud quasars, in good
agreement with current unified models for radio-loud AGN,
taking into account stellar evolution in the elliptical host
galaxies. There is a trend between the host and nuclear
luminosity for the most luminous FSRQs, supporting the
suggestion based on studies of lower redshift AGN, that there
is a minimum host galaxy luminosity which increases linearly
with the quasar luminosity.
Together with Falomo and Scarpa, Kotilainen also studied the
near-infrared properties of the host galaxies of a sample of BL
Lac objects. The host galaxy was clearly detected in all low
redshift (z < 0.25) BL Lacs. The galaxies hosting the low
redshift BL Lacs are large and luminous, slightly brighter than
L*, but slightly fainter than the brightest cluster galaxies.
The optical/near-infrared colour and colour gradient of the BL
Lac hosts are similar to normal ellipticals, indicating that
the nuclear activity has little effect on the star formation
history of the hosts. The nucleus-to-galaxy luminosity ratio of
the BL Lacs is similar to that of low redshift radio galaxies
and consistent with what is found in previous optical studies
of BL Lacs. However, it is smaller that that of the FSRQs,
suggesting there is a difference in the intrinsic brightness of
the nuclear source or in the Doppler beaming factor between the
two types of blazars.
L. Takalo, A. Sillanpää, K. Nilsson, T. Pursimo and
collaborators (J. Heidt, Heidelberg, Germany, S.A. Laurent-
Muehleisen, LLNL, USA and W. Brinkmann, MPI, Germany) have been
conducting a project to study the host galaxies and environments
of BL Lac objects. During the last few years several studies
have shown that at least some BL Lacs belong to small clusters
and many objects seem to have close companion galaxies. This has
raised the question about the role of the close environment to the
BL Lac phenomenon. To answer this question a number BL Lac
samples are being studied using the Nordic Optical Telescope
(NOT). These include the 1 Jy radio-selected sample, the EMSSX-
ray sample and the both radio and X-ray selected RGB (ROSAT -
Green Bank) sample. Observing time to study the gamma ray
selected EGRET BL Lacs has also been received.
So far more than 100 objects have been imaged at the NOT,
mostly in good seeing conditions (FWHM ~1.0 arcsec or better).
The main aim of these studies is to separate the host galaxy
light from the nuclear light to study the host galaxy
properties and the immediate environment of the BL Lac. This is
achieved by fitting two-dimensional galaxy + nucleus models to
the observed images. Methods to analyze the images are
currently being developed and tested at Tuorla Observatory.
These methods have already been successfully applied to a small
sample of EINSTEIN Slew Survey BL Lacs (by Heidt et al.).
The objects imaged so far seem to lie in very interesting
neighborhoods. Most of the objects have close companion
galaxies and sometimes clear signs of gravitational interaction
is seen. In one case we found a blue arc close to the BL Lac
(Fig. 1). Further observations at the NOT showed that this arc
is a gravitationally distorted image of a more distant
background galaxy, the first of its kind found close to a BL
Lac object. Closer to the nucleus many interesting features
have been seen. For instance, an optical jet coincident with
the radio jet was found in 3C 371 and in BL Lac itself a disk
component was discovered.
A composite colour image of
RGB1745+398 (the large reddish galaxy left of the center) and
the gravitational arc close to it (the bluish arc southeast of
the galaxy).
In collaboration with Yu. Baryshev (St.Petersburg), V. Sokolov
(SAO), and S. Zharikov (SAO), M. Hanski, K. Nilsson, and P.
Teerikorpi have investigated the nature of the host galaxy of
the gamma ray burst GRB970508. First optically identified at the
NOT, the optical transient of GRB970508 was photometrically
measured by the 6-m telescope in BVRcIc
bands several times
during the year following the outburts in 1997-98. These
observations allowed one to detect the contribution that the
faint host galaxy gave to the photometry and derive its B-
magnitude and broad-band colours, and also the KB correction
(at z = 0.835, the redshift measured by Keck). The K-corrected
B-absolute magnitude of the host is about -18.5 mag (for H0 =
60 km/s/Mpc), 2.5 mag fainter than the knee in the local
general Schechter luminosity function.
The broad-band spectrum of the host is incompatible with the
spectra of normal local galaxies earlier than Sbc. It fits
best with a Scd starburst galaxy and a blue compact galaxy. The
host's position in the absolute magnitude vs. size diagram
indicates that its surface brightness is significantly higher
than is typical for local late-type galaxies from the LEDA
extragalactic database.
In another deep universe collaboration with Russian
astronomers, going on for a few years, the RATAN radio galaxies
have been studied by T. Pursimo, K. Nilsson, and P. Teerikorpi
together with Yu. Baryshev (St.Petersburg) and the RATAN group
of Yu. Parijskij (St.Petersburg). In 1998 the analysis of the
NOT subarcsecond observations of about 20 radio galaxies was
completed. These morphological and colour observations form a
part of the effort to create a complete sample of faint, very
distant radio galaxies around the narrow RATAN strip in the
sky.
The linear Hubble redshift-distance law and the
fractal density-distance law with D ~ 2 in same spatial scales.
The displayed Hubble law is based (in the order of increasing
distance) to galaxies with Cepheid distances, galaxies with
Tully-Fisher distances, and to galaxies with distances from
Supernovae of Ia type. The fractal law is based on the gamma
function analysis of several redshift surveys (CfA1, Perseus-
Pisces, LCRS, ESP, LEDA). This surprising co-existence of two
cosmological laws was studied by Baryshev et al. (1998).
Seyfert galaxies
J. Kotilainen presented optical B-I continuum colour maps of a
large sample of Seyfert 2 galaxies. Extended blue continuum
components were detected in the circumnuclear region of several
galaxies, either elongated or forming a double structure across
the nucleus. They are closely aligned with the radio and
emission line axes of these galaxies and probably arise from
scattering of nuclear continuum light by extranuclear mirrors.
The colours of the blue maxima are consistent with those
expected from scattering off dust or electrons. These findings
thus strongly support the current unified models of AGN.
BL Lac Phenomenon meeting
During June 22-26, 1998 L.O. Takalo and A. Sillanpää organized
an international meeting in Turku on "BL Lac Phenomenon". This
meeting was the result of some discussions about two years
earlier, during which they were asked to organize such a
meeting. The meeting was the third in a series of BL Lac
meetings, previous ones being Pittsburgh 1978 and Como 1988. It
was attended by 120 astronomers from over 20 countries, to
discuss our current knowledge and the future of BL Lac
research. Meeting presentations will be published in the PASP
conference series.
|